Here are my notes: – discursive texts are not discussion essays, although they have some commonalities including: considering different perspectives on a topic, writing strong paragraphs on each perspective with supporting evidence, selecting a preferred position and articulating reasons for choice but not in a forceful way.It is unlike a discussion essay in that it does not need to be formal or objective in tone, however, it can have formal and objective aspects.– discursive texts are a offer and not a demand.We ended up having about a 40 minute conversation, putting forward many ideas, with me looking through things I’ve written about persuasive texts for textbooks and about personal essays trying to see if I knew what I was on about.Tags: Graphic Design Problem SolvingVideo Game Violence Research PaperCar Washing Business PlanAnti Gun Control Thesis StatementResearch Paper WebquestPhd Dissertation EltSchubert Winterreise EssaysCollege Essay Help In Bay AreaUse Of Appendices In Thesis
For example, if you were writing a paper against the death penalty, you might say, "I acknowledge that murderers deserve the most severe punishment society has, but I believe the death penalty should not be used because it can lead to the execution of innocent people." Isaiah David is a freelance writer and musician living in Portland, Ore.
He has over five years experience as a professional writer and has been published on various online outlets.
As a lover of language and literature, I’m stoked to finally have some freedom and flexibility in the English Stage 6 Syllabus, the kids, I am discovering, are less stoked.
Anyway, I had been messaging Darcy early in the morning, so when I got to school I, of course, continued the subject with my English colleagues – they too are feeling a bit confused and stressed about this new form.
One of my colleagues asked me to write up our conversation because we covered so much, and I did this as best as I could.
I thought I’d share those note with you, but please know, I am not posting this to claim any authority at all over a definition of this form, just that this is where we are at, and I’m happy to move forward on this writing journey with my students now that I’ve talked it all out.A discursive essay, sometimes called a argument essay, is a critical analysis of a controversial topic that supports an opinion about that topic.The writer of a discursive essay attempts to present both sides of an issue, while showing why one side has greater merit.So, when I am confused and seeking clarity and wisdom, what do I do? You know how HSC English now requires students to write discursive essays as well as persuasive and imaginative… I’ve always referred to them as personal essays, but looking at the NESA definition of discursive, I think that’s what he does. This should be a blog post TBH but just would love your advice as you’re my most knowledgeable Orwell friend. Darcy’s concern is similar to mine, the NESA definition could pretty much include any text ever – my students and I had a laugh about this actually.He obviously has an agenda or position on his focus topic, and he is quite persuasive, but he also does a great job outlining arguments for and against and then settles on his own position, which he makes clear by the end. I’m teaching PATEL now and we’ve set students a discursive essay task in response, and I am going to get them to use Orwell’s style as their model… TBH, my laugh was hearty, and theirs a bit nervous – it’s stressful for them feeling uncertain.However everyone must agree that now it is hard to imagine the world without technology.In this essay I look at the good and bad side of technology.He holds a degree in creative writing from the University of Michigan.Some people believe that technology is bad, other people believe that technology is fantastic.In other words, they offer a range of insights into a particular topic, but don’t demand that the reader accept only one of these positions as definitive– discursive texts have some features in common with persuasive essays – rhetorical devices, personal voice – but they differ in purpose, as the persuasive text puts forward arguments to support a predetermined position/opinion, whereas a discursive piece considers other opinions also, even if the writer might not agree with that opinion– lines of argument about the chosen topic are supported with evidence, this may be personal experience/anecdotes, statistics, quotes from experts, reference to shared human experiences, descriptions of events etc– Orwell’s essays are called personal essays because they put forward his personal opinion on a chosen topic, have a strong personal voice, and often have the purpose of ‘exposing some lie’, therefore are more persuasive than a discursive essay.However, the personal essay has a lot in common with a discursive text in that it is a discussion/dialogue on a topic of interest, presents a range of arguments about the topic, support arguments/points with evidence, is designed to engage the reader as well as inform them about the topic, the personal essay, like the discursive form, appeals to the heart, mind and imagination of the reader (well, I think so anyway! )– finally, I would say that discursive texts can be pretty much anything, haha.